🐜AssistAnt · Pro directory
There are 185 auto repair shops within 25 miles of Shelter Island, NY in the AssistAnt directory as of November 8, 2026, 1 of them based in Shelter Island itself. None are verified by AssistAnt yet, so check a business’s license and insurance before you hire it. Ranked by activity, never paid: members who pressed Boost this week come first, then verified and claimed businesses, then businesses whose website we checked, then everyone else nearest first. No one can pay for a higher spot.
Auto repair near Shelter Island
Ranked by activity, never paid. Boosted this week first, then verified and claimed, then website checked, then everyone else nearest first. Not on this list? Add yourself free →
- Bridgehampton Autosport
Bridgehampton, NY · 8.9 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 237-1111 Website ↗
- Lease A Car
East Hampton, NY · 10.6 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 515-7055 Website ↗
- East Coast Custom Cars
Southampton, NY · 10.9 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 283-4531 Website ↗
- Mike's Townline Service Center
Westbrook, CT · 15.5 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 399-1206 Website ↗
- Mal's Auto and Truck Repair
Old Saybrook, CT · 15.7 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 395-1214 Website ↗
- Coastal Performance Llc
Old Saybrook, CT · 15.9 mi
Not verified yet
(203) 216-9999 Website ↗
- Chris' Auto Repair Shop
Westbrook, CT · 16.4 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 399-0699 Website ↗
- Willy's Repair Shop
Hampton Bays, NY · 16.8 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 856-4200 Website ↗
- Inline Autoworks
Niantic, CT · 18.4 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 451-8254 Website ↗
- Tire Country
Riverhead, NY · 19.2 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 369-2600 Website ↗
- Brookhaven Auto Electric
Riverhead, NY · 19.2 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 727-4565 Website ↗
- Essex Marine Group
Essex, CT · 19.8 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 767-4999 Website ↗
- Sea Tow
Montauk, NY · 20.8 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 260-1818 Website ↗
- Timeless Classics Auto Service
Quogue, NY · 21.2 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 996-2957 Website ↗
- MC Repairs
Quogue, NY · 21.7 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 871-3468 Website ↗
- Dynamic Automotive
Riverhead, NY · 22.7 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 727-7666 Website ↗
- Auto Hub Plus
New London, CT · 23.1 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 831-3064 Website ↗
- North Collision Body Shop
New London, CT · 23.2 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 442-0393 Website ↗
- Palumbo's Automotive Unlimited
Guilford, CT · 23.8 mi
Not verified yet
(203) 453-1788 Website ↗
- S & S Transmission and Auto Repair
Groton, CT · 24.1 mi
Not verified yet
(860) 215-4752 Website ↗
- Hubbard's Repair Shop
Shelter Island, NY · 0.4 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 749-2020 No website on file
- Detailing
Greenport, NY · 2.9 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 384-7602
- Port Automotive Repair Inc
Greenport, NY · 3.0 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 477-2332 No website on file
- Sea Tow Services International
Southold, NY · 4.8 mi
Not verified yet
(800) 473-2869
- Southold Automotive Corp.Auto Repair Of Southold
Southold, NY · 4.9 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 765-5156
- Willow Hill Automotive
Southold, NY · 5.1 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 765-4906
- A To Z Auto Radiator and Air Conditioning
Southold, NY · 5.2 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 765-6849
- Noyac Service Station
Sag Harbor, NY · 5.6 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 725-1155 No website on file
- Gregs Garage
Sag Harbor, NY · 5.6 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 725-1111
- East End Towing & Recovery
Southold, NY · 5.7 mi
Not verified yet
(631) 766-1707 No website on file
Showing the 30 listed first. Search by ZIP code to see more.
More near Shelter Island
Same order as above, continued.
Questions
- How many auto repair shops are near Shelter Island, NY?
- 185 within 25 miles, 1 in Shelter Island, as of November 8, 2026.
- Which auto repair shops near Shelter Island, NY are verified?
- None yet. Verified means AssistAnt checked the business registration and insurance; unverified listings come from public business records.
- Can a business pay to rank higher on AssistAnt?
- No. Ranked by activity, never paid: members who pressed Boost this week come first, then verified and claimed businesses, then businesses whose website we checked, then everyone else nearest first. No one can pay for a higher spot. AssistAnt never sells your contact information.
Nearby towns
- Sag Harbor, NY 5 mi
- Southold, NY 5 mi
- East Hampton, NY 8 mi
- Bridgehampton, NY 9 mi
- Cutchogue, NY 9 mi
- Water Mill, NY 11 mi
- Southampton, NY 12 mi
- Amagansett, NY 12 mi
- Mattituck, NY 12 mi
- Jamesport, NY 15 mi